| (1) | 4:36.72 | CBP | Emelia Gorecka | (Aldershot, Farnham & District AC) | 1 FINAL | Kingsmeadow Stadium | 11 May 2008 |
| (2) | 4:37.64 | | Katherine Shiel-Rankin | (Aldershot, Farnham & District AC) | 1 FINAL | Kingsmeadow Stadium | 12 May 2012 |
| (3) | 4:39.52 | | Maisie Collis | (Herne Hill Harriers) | 1 FINAL | Kingsmeadow Stadium | 14 May 2017 |
| (4) | 4:40.14 | | Georgia Peel | (Woking AC) | 2 FINAL | Kingsmeadow Stadium | 11 May 2008 |
| (5) | 4:40.26 | | Poppy Guest | (Aldershot, Farnham & District AC) | 1 FINAL | Kingsmeadow Stadium | 12 May 2024 |
| (6) | 4:41.1 | CBP | Karen Sutton | (Croydon Harriers) | 1 FINAL | Motspur Park | 18 May 1985 |
| (7) | 4:41.77 | | Kitty Scott | (Aldershot, Farnham & District AC) | 2 FINAL | Kingsmeadow Stadium | 12 May 2024 |
| (8) | 4:41.78 | | Maisie Collis | (Herne Hill Harriers) | 1 FINAL | Kingsmeadow Stadium | 13 May 2018 |
| (9) | 4:41.79 | | Katy-Ann McDonald | (Blackheath & Bromley Harriers AC) | 1 FINAL | Kingsmeadow Stadium | 24 May 2014 |
| (10) | 4:42.19 | | Eugenie Cockle | (Aldershot, Farnham & District AC) | 2 FINAL | Kingsmeadow Stadium | 24 May 2014 |
| |
| 10 performances of 4:42.19 or better. |
